Monday, February 24, 2020

Off the Map: The Muffletta That Divided a Nation

Muffaletta -- Johnny's Po Boys, New Orleans, LA

The one thing you need to know about the muffaletta is that Ginger hates it.
HATES. IT.
During her own trip to New Orleans many moons ago, she stumbled upon Johnny's Po Boys and dutifully ordered the sandwich, recommended by Scott Conant on the NEW ORLEANS episode of Best Thing I Ever Ate. Needless to say, it did not go well.
The Restaurant That Launched a Thousand Olive-Based Grievances
Not only did Ginger complain about it at the time, but she has spent the subsequent years rehashing what a waste of time and calories the "monstrosity" (her word) was. Naturally, for all of these reasons, Vodka is DYING to try it, just to see what Ginger has been bellyaching about all this time.
Preparing to Be Horrified
 And guys? The muffaletta is delicious. 
Beginning to Question the Trustworthiness of Ginger's Tastebuds
Stumbling into Johnny's Po Boys for the day's second breakfast, Vodka and Whiskey Sour find the place bustling with a mostly local, mostly male contingent. When we place our order for one muffaletta, we are confronted with the baffling question: toasted or cold cuts? Ummmm. Which one will not result in the version that left Ginger ranting and raving for a decade?
Because We Want That One
Our cashier recommends the toasted option, and we settle against the wall to wait, taking note of the beverage display, where alcohol is being sold directly next to the orange juice.
We Love a Place That Serves Breakfast Booze
Just like our friends at Restaurant August, Johnny's Po Boys kindly splits our sandwich in half and gives us each our own plate. Thankfully, we only ordered one, as the muffaletta is enormous. 
Good Thing This Is Today's Last Planned Breakfast...
Stacked high with various deli meats of the salami and ham varieties, it is enclosed between two giant pieces of circular sesame bread. Melted cheese oozes out the sides, holding all the components together, while an olive salad peeks out between the layers.
And More Often Than Not, Falls Out the Sides
Diving in for our first bites, we are understandably skeptical. Based on our shoddy memories, we believe the main component that Ginger was railing against were the olives, and granted, one does need to enjoy olives in order to like this sandwich. However, Vodka is far from an olive connoisseur (she mostly likes them just in her martinis), but she is not offended by them in this capacity. 
Olives Best Served Stirred, Not Shaken
At first, we are impressed by the muffaletta mostly because of how much we expected to hate it. But after we later wind up at the bitter end of a multi-hour boat cruise, cold and starving, Vodka wishes she had packed the remainder of her sandwich to go, thus proving it to be even more pleasing after some time away.
Makes for a Perfect Breakfast and/or Midnight Snack
Of course, that opinion stands in stark contrast to Ginger's, where distance has only made her muffaletta-hating heart more hostile. Which maybe proves that all culinary delights are in the eyes, and the tastebuds, of the beholder.

Johnny's Po Boys's Muffaletta: 4 stars

No comments:

Post a Comment